Last November, I sold my condo in Los Angeles and found myself in deep discussions with my real estate agent, reviewing offers, considering options, and calculating costs. Around the same time, I met with a couple of startup founders at a coffee shop in San Francisco to discuss their hiring plans for 2025. They recently closed a seed round of funding and were planning for a ramp-up, recognizing the need for recruitment support to help build a team efficiently.
And that's when it hit me—hiring an employee is a lot like buying a house.
At first, it may seem like an odd comparison. After all, one is about real estate, and the other is about talent. But both involve a significant investment that, if done right, can pay off for years to come—whether you're looking to build a business or a home.
In both scenarios, you're seeking something that fits your needs and aligns with your long-term goals. Just like buying a house, hiring requires careful thought and strategic planning to ensure a good fit.
Here are three crucial steps to help you make more informed, confident decisions as you begin your hiring process:
Step 1: Defining Needs & Expectations 📝
When you set out to buy a house, you ask yourself essential questions: How many bedrooms do I need? What’s my budget? Which neighborhood aligns with my lifestyle? These questions help narrow your options and avoid wasting time on properties that won’t meet your needs.
Similarly, the hiring process demands clarity from the start. Before you begin searching for candidates, take the time to define the role. What specific problem will this person solve? What key skills and experiences are necessary to reach your goals? Just like you wouldn’t buy a house without a clear idea of what’s essential, you shouldn’t start recruiting without a well-defined understanding of the role’s requirements.
Early-stage startups often ask candidates to complete tasks, such as solving engineering problems or preparing presentations, to demonstrate their skills and then base their hiring decisions on the candidates' performance. While this approach can provide valuable insights, it’s more effective to first define the role clearly. Knowing exactly what the position requires allows you to design tasks that are relevant and assess the most critical skills, ensuring a more strategic and aligned hiring decision.
Start by creating two lists: “Must-Haves” and “Nice-to-Haves.” Identifying these core requirements ensures you focus on the essential skills needed for the role and avoid unnecessary assessments down the line.
This process not only clarifies what you truly need but also helps align your team, ensuring everyone is on the same page when selecting the right candidate.
Step 2: Calculating Benefits vs. Costs 💰
When buying a house, you're making a long-term investment. You weigh the benefits—building equity, having a place to call your own—against the costs, including mortgage payments, property taxes, and maintenance expenses. Similarly, when hiring an employee, it’s crucial to evaluate the costs (salary, benefits, training) against the long-term value they can bring.
Consider these factors:
Business Development: Will this hire increase revenue or streamline operations?
Skill Acquisition: Will you save time and resources by bringing in someone with specialized expertise, or can the role be trained internally?
Operational Efficiency: Will this person help improve processes and reduce costs elsewhere in the business?
Strategic Focus: How much more time will you free up to focus on critical business growth when you have the right person in this role?
Collaborate with your Finance team to calculate the total cost, including hidden expenses like onboarding and initial productivity dips. If the benefits outweigh the costs, it’s worth moving forward—just as you’d make an offer on a house that promises long-term value.
Step 3: Factoring in the Costs 💸
When buying a house, you know the upfront price isn’t the only cost to consider. There are property taxes, maintenance fees, HOA fees, insurance, and other ongoing expenses that can add up over time. Similarly, when hiring an employee, it's crucial to factor in more than just their salary.
Here are some costs to consider:
Base salary and benefits: Just like a house payment, this is the main, recurring cost. But don’t forget about the additional costs like health insurance, retirement contributions, and other benefits.
Equipment and software: Think of this as the “furnishing” of your hire. It includes things like a laptop, phone, software licenses, and other tools needed to perform their job effectively. Just as you wouldn’t move into a house without the necessary appliances, don’t overlook these essential resources.
Taxes, insurance, and other administrative costs: Similar to property taxes and homeowner’s insurance, hiring an employee comes with mandatory costs like payroll taxes, workers' compensation, and other regulatory expenses.
Training, onboarding, and supervision: This is like the initial renovations you might need to do when moving into a new house. Getting an employee up to speed often requires training, onboarding processes, and time from other team members to supervise and guide them.
Understanding these costs in advance helps you make informed decisions. If the long-term benefits outweigh these expenses, it’s a green light to move forward. If not, consider other options. This comprehensive cost analysis allows you to budget more accurately and assess the potential return on investment.
Exploring Alternatives: Take Your Time ⏳
In house-hunting, you’ve likely heard, “Act quickly—this property won’t last long!” The same urgency often applies to hiring, but rushing can lead to costly mistakes. It’s crucial to take your time and conduct thorough due diligence when making hiring decisions.
The pressure to fill a role quickly is understandable, especially when you’re eager to keep things moving. However, slowing down can help you avoid regrets. I recall a situation where a hiring manager was eager to make an offer based solely on a strong recommendation from their network. They didn’t take the time to understand the candidate’s motivations, assess cultural fit, or consider team dynamics. Red flags appeared almost immediately after the candidate’s first day, and ultimately, the working relationship didn’t last. This could have been easily avoided with a more thoughtful hiring process.
Have you ever heard the phrase “Hire fast, fire faster”? I have and it may sound harsh, but it’s really about making thoughtful decisions and being transparent with both new hires and existing team members.
Hiring mistakes happen—it doesn’t mean the person is bad; it simply means they weren’t the right fit for the role or team.
One reason leaders often hold on to someone who isn’t a good fit is the reluctance to admit a hiring mistake. It’s tempting to justify the decision rather than face the reality of the situation. Another reason is the discomfort of letting someone go, especially when the need for a body in the role feels urgent. But the truth is, keeping the wrong person is ultimately more painful than making the tough call to part ways.
This challenge is particularly common for founders, who may feel emotionally invested in a candidate they’re excited about, leading to the temptation to hire too quickly. However, it’s crucial to slow down and thoroughly vet candidates. Conduct reference checks, have back-channel conversations, and ask insightful questions during interviews.
Rushed hires often lead to regret and HR issues down the road. Before moving forward, consider these alternatives:
Contractor vs. Full-Time Employee: Would hiring a contractor or consultant provide the expertise you need without a long-term commitment?
Outsourcing: Could specific tasks be outsourced rather than bringing on a new full-time employee?
Training Early-Career Talent: Could you hire a less experienced candidate and invest in their growth, building long-term loyalty while saving costs upfront?
Improving Existing Systems: Can process improvements or internal solutions eliminate the need for a new hire?
Weighing your options helps you avoid hiring mistakes and builds a stronger foundation for your team and business. Sometimes, the smartest move is to wait.
Make an Informed, Confident Decision 💪
Just as you wouldn’t purchase a house without considering all your options and doing the necessary homework—such as inspections and reviewing disclosures—take the time to carefully evaluate your hiring needs.
Ask yourself:
Am I willing to pay top dollar for a strong candidate, or would I be open to training someone with potential?
Could this role be done remotely, offering greater flexibility and access to a broader talent pool?
Is this person essential for our immediate goals, or can we delay the hire until later?
It’s important to remember that there’s no such thing as a perfect candidate. Sometimes, candidates will only be able to do about 80% of the job right away, but if they have the potential to grow and learn, it’s often worth taking the chance.
The 80/20 rule can be a great way to evaluate talent—look for a candidate who can do 80% of the role now and has the potential to grow into the rest.
Creating a Positive Candidate Experience 💖
With the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), it’s become a competitive market in certain sectors. Potential employees are evaluating you just as much as you’re evaluating them. Present a competitive offer that reflects their worth. When candidates see that you’re serious and ready to make a decision, they’re more likely to choose your offer over others.
However, be mindful of “buyer’s remorse.” Just as you wouldn’t rush into purchasing a home without careful consideration, the same applies to hiring. If the offer isn’t competitive or doesn’t align with the candidate’s expectations, it can lead to regret on both sides.
After extending an offer and receiving an acceptance, keep the candidate engaged with regular communication until their start date. A simple check-in text or email shows that you’re committed to them joining your team. As a hiring manager, you have the opportunity to start building a positive working relationship as soon as they say “yes” to the offer.
These little gestures keep them excited and committed to the opportunity, reducing the chances of second thoughts.
Final Thought: Make the Right Hire, Build a Strong Foundation 🏗️
As a startup founder, hiring may seem like a daunting task, especially if it’s new to you. But by approaching the process thoughtfully—like buying a home—you’ll be better prepared to make decisions that will bring lasting value to your business.
Take your time, define your needs, weigh the costs and benefits, and trust your judgment.
Remember: making the right hire is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as you build your team. Like purchasing the perfect home, it can shape the future of your business for years to come.
Ready to hire? Take the first step by clarifying your needs today. At BullishIQ, we’re here to help you build the team from the ground up.
Stay bullish—let’s make it happen.
BullishIQ is a recruitment intelligence group that helps startups hire top talent through a unique "talent-as-a-service" model. This embedded approach empowers organizations to meet hiring needs from the ground up while maintaining the flexibility to scale up or down as market conditions change. When you flex, we flex with you.
Comments